Skip to main content

Caseville, MI (and the surrounding area) Restaurants

Caseville, MI and the surrounding area restaurants vary in style offering a unique culinary experience. From cozy cafes serving up comforting classics to waterfront eateries offering fresh seafood with a view, there's something to satisfy every taste. Feast on local delicacies, savor freshly caught lake fare or enjoy a casual meal with friends and family. Whether you're craving comfort food, international cuisine, or fine dining, Caseville's restaurants promise a memorable dining experience in the heart of Michigan's Thumb region

Beachy’s Restaurant

A modern family restaurant with indoor/outdoor seating proudly serving an evolving menu complete with seasonal cocktails. Outdoor entertainment is provided by an assortment of local artisans during the peak summer season, weather permitting.

(989) 856-1159
Directions
Website
2.3 Miles
Dufty’s Blue Water Inn

A full-service bar with a complete menu offering a variety of options including an assortment of hamburgers, pizza, salads, and entrees check out the daily specials and an array of cocktails. Enjoy playing pool, darts and Michigan Lottery – Keno in addition to music and dancing on the weekends. Blue Water Inn is open 7 days a week year-round. Daily specials.

(989) 856-3400
Directions
Website
2.3 Miles
The Thumb Brewery

Providing the adventures of craft beer & community, Thumb Brewery offers the laid-back culture of Caseville and the love of beer, chilling out with friends and family, and great pub food. 

(989) 553-6758
Directions
Website
2.4 Miles
The Crawford - coming Summer 2026

The Crawford, named after one of Caseville's early setters,, Francis Crawford is proudly serving good mood food with crave-worthy bites, a boutique wine assortment, craft cocktails, and ice cold beer.  Complete with a menu of exciting options for every palate, there is indoor and outdoor seating and plenty of onsite parking. Enjoy your next culinary delight at The Crawford. 

(989) 856-1240
Directions
2.7 Miles
Lefty’s Diner

The feel of a 1950’s diner with a beach vibe makes Lefty’s Diner an ideal option for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The menu is filled with an assortment of burgers and specialty sandwiches to delight the palate especially when coupled with handmade milk shakes and malts. Daily specials.

(989) 856-8899
Directions
Website
2.8 Miles
Huron Co BBQ

Huron Co BBQ is a Texas inspired BBQ with the most amazing assortment of smoked meats, Smashburgers, delightful local craft beers and sports of all sorts on their jumbo 100" television. Located in the heart of Pigeon (a short drive from Fox's Lodge) and open-year round. See their Facebook page for their daily hours of operations. Gluten free options available.

(989) 453-4227
Directions
Website
10.8 Miles
The Farm Restaurant

A charming farmhouse style restaurant with a full menu packed with seasonal favorites including delectable cocktails, appetizers, entrees, and an assortment of desserts you won’t want to miss. Off season specialty events are a ‘must attend’ with enjoyable themes. The Farm is an ideal choice for special occasions. Reservations are highly encouraged.

(989) 874-5700
Directions
Website
12.1 Miles
Fireside Inn

An authentic lodge environment offering an extensive menu with everything from pizza, ribs, seafood, subs, burgers, and cocktails. A children’s menu and a family arcade is available for the little ones in your group. Seasonal hours.  

(989) 738-8232
Directions
Website
13.2 Miles
The Pasta House

Proudly serving the community for more than 30 years. A renovated old bank has grown into a warm, family-friendly restaurant known for hearty homemade pastas, fresh pizzas, and comfort food made with love. Not to mention the ribs making it completely worth the drive.  The Pasta House has become more than just a restaurant — it’s where birthdays are celebrated, weddings are toasted, and neighbors become friends. The staff looks forward to sharing their table with you. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or part of our extended Pasta House family, they look forward to welcoming you. While their kitchen is not gluten-free, there are gluten-free options available.

(989) 550-2218
Directions
Website
16.6 Miles
Bird Creek Farms

A tap room and restaurant with inside and outside dining. The menu offers a delicious assortment of shareables, handhelds, and entrees and an imaginative array of masterfully mixed cocktails and refreshing beverages. Reservations are encouraged.

(989) 553-6444
Directions
Website
16.7 Miles